5 Navigation Website Design Errors

5 Navigation Website Design Errors

There are few things more frustrating on the web than not being able to find what you are looking for on a website. After all, you came there with a purpose, invested your time, clicked your mouse. The least the website designer could have done was provide a cogent, intuitive layout for you to follow!

This is part of our Website Design Errors series. You should be able to see the entire Web Design Errors series.

No one expects you, the website owner, or your designer to be mind-readers. But there are a certain number of best practices you can use to make sure your site helps your visitors and keeps them happy. Here I break them into Navigation errors – the getting from place to place.

Top 5 Ways to Poor Website Navigation

1) Missing ‘Home’ button, or Menu Bar
Nothing more basic than this. Sometimes your user will follow a link and be directed to the exact content they were searching for. Sometimes they won’t. Be sure to provide a way for them to access the top hierarchical content of your site with a home page link and other core resources. Key pages are also great to have on a single, persistent navigation bar. Whatever your method, keep the navigating consistent across all pages. There is no reason to make a user re-learn how to use your website because they are in a different section.

2) Broken back button
Like we just covered, sometimes you click on something by mistake and you want to go back to your previous page. Everyone is trained to click the back button. Some power users navigate by using the keypad. It is very frustrating when the back button does not work. A prime example of this are flash-based websites where, because of the nature of flash, no matter how deep you are into the site clicking the back button brings you all the way back to the beginning! Flash is evil.

3) No Search Functionality
Any website with even a moderate amount of pages will not be able to serve every viewers need immediately. Why not cut to the chase and offer a search box so the user can find exactly what she is looking for? If your website visitors cannot find what they are looking for immediately, they will leave.

4) Broken Links
Not much to say here. When you click on a link, you expect it to take you to a new page. Broken links look unprofessional and interrupt the user’s flow. Find your broken links and fix them with .htaccess or metatag redirects.

Be sure to include an automated 404 error so your website handles broken links gracefully. Michael Donohoe, a developer for the NY Times agrees. “If something goes wrong, help your visitor! Custom and helpful error messages with meaningful information are a huge asset and often forgotten about.”

(Note: If you are unsure what a 404 page is or how to set one up, drop a note and I will create a ‘How to’ page.)

4a) Suspect Links

Each link you have leading away from your site can be considered a vote for the integrity of that site – both by your users and by search engines. Make sure your links are helpful and trustworthy.

Consider your audience – if you’re trying to sell a quality product, don’t include links to other sites (no matter how tempting) unless you know their product or service is at least as good as yours. People make assumptions and if you link to another site, they’ll assume you recommend it. If that leads to a bad experience, it’ll reflect badly on your site not just the linked one. –
Tracy Willis

5) Silly Introduction Pages
Give the user what they want. Your Home Page should be a like a point guard – assessing the situation and passing the user off to where he wants / needs to be. When the front page instead shows a time-consuming flash presentation or video, the distribution of information becomes inhibited. How many NBA point guards will be sent to the bench if they can’t pass the rock?

Siddharth Sethi, the CEO InfoBeans put it to me this way: “I think a flash introduction that adds no value is a total let down for me. Using flash to create a splash page only to have 90% users click the skip button is a waste of everyone’s time.”

Bonus Error – The Unnecessary

Again from Tracy:

Anything that gets in your audiences’ way – intro’s, irrelevant pop-ups, too many adverts, poor content, unnecessary ‘extra’ pages. People go to websites to do something – whether its shopping, interacting with friends, watching films, researching a product/service etc – they go with an intent in mind. If you randomly put unnecessary ‘stuff’ in the way, you won’t hold their attention for long or you’ll irritate them. Either way its not a good experience.


In the end, it is all about making it as easy as possible for a user to get from point A to point B, and remain happy in the process.

Thanks to everyone who sent input to this article. If you didn’t get a chance, here’s your shot. What kind of poor website navigation design (or lack of design) drives you to distraction? Let us know, below.

{ 5 comments… read them below or add one }

Seth Stacey October 23, 2008 at 3:48 pm

It is sad that a lot of those problems are due to excited flash developers, but those are problems are not nearly as prevalent as they were a few years ago.

Definitely agree with the broken links thing. That screams unprofessional.


CWD October 23, 2008 at 6:35 pm

That is true. But have you noticed the proliferation of flash intros on US candidate websites lately? I’m not sure they got the notice! Thanks for visiting and commenting Seth.


Seth Stacey October 23, 2008 at 10:34 pm

Wow, I didn’t notice that. I just looked up a few senators sites, and I am annoyed (even though I was expecting it! ).

Obama’s site was the most annoying, yet actually effective. I didn’t even know that wasn’t the site at first.


CWD October 24, 2008 at 6:55 am

I was put off by Obama’s flash intro, too. When I am surfing, I am generally looking for information. Anything that gets in the way of what I am looking for irritates me. Clicking through flash intros is very high on the list.

One thing that is interesting about it is the A/B marketing testing they do: displaying different flash videos and measuring the results. I do wonder what exactly they are measuring exactly. I’m sure it would be interesting.

Look for an article here comparing and contrasting McCain and Obama’s website designs here early next week.


CWD June 21, 2009 at 9:36 am

Thanks, Rocky. Glad you enjoyed it!


Leave a Comment


Previous post:

Next post: